kessi-cpa Library logo (2.72 KB)
Home
Accounting
Taxation
Bookkeeping
Share
Ask Question
×

Accounting Standards for Private Enterprises (ASPE)

MEASUREMENT OF INVENTORIES

CPA Canada Handbook – Accounting, section 3031, paragraph 10 requires inventories to be measured at the lower of cost and net realizable value

Explanation

For some businesses, inventory represents a sizeable portion of their assets, up to 80% in some cases. Users of the financial statements need to know whether the funds invested in inventories are recoverable. If the costs of inventories are recoverable, users need to know the cost; if they are not recoverable, they need to know the realizable value (how much the business expect to obtain from selling those inventories) A good example would be a bank advancing a loan to a company holding inventory that represents 50% of its assets. In such situations, inventory is often provided as collateral for the loan. The bank is interested in knowing whether the company will be able to pay back the loan and the interest. Simply explained, if the company sells the inventories for an amount less than what it paid for, then it will generate less money and will be less capable of paying back its debts. So, in making a decision whether to extend the loan or not, the bank needs to know the recoverable value of those inventories and measure the financial capacity of the company to pay back its debts.

The CPA standard above aims to provide users with useful information about inventories by requiring entities to measure inventories at the lower of cost and net realizable value - the inventory balance reported on the balance sheet cannot be more than the net realizable value. If the net realizable value is less than the cost, the inventory should be written down and measured at the net realizable value.

Scale (5.41kb)

What is the cost?

The cost of inventories includes purchase costs, conversion costs and other costs incurred to bring the inventories to their present location and condition. Purchase costs includes the price paid to purchase the goods, import duties and other taxes, handling and shipping costs, and all other costs attributable to purchase the finished goods, materials and suppliers, and services. Conversion costs refer to the costs incurred to make the good ready for sale. These include labor costs and allocated fixed and variable production costs.

What is the net realizable value?

The net realizable value refers to the selling price of the goods less the estimated cost of completion and the estimated costs necessary to make the sale. When the net realizable value is lower than the cost, we say that the cost is not recoverable.

Example:

Company ABC is a newly created company specialized in the retail business of one product, flat screen televisions, Bix Model 500. The company uses the perpetual method of inventory to account for its inventories, and its year end is December 31, 2018. On 1 October 2018, Company ABC purchased 10 televisions for $2,000 ($200 each). Here is the journal entry that was recorded by Company ABC in its books:

Inventory – Televisions 2,000
Bank 2,000

On November 15, 2018, The Company sold 2 televisions for $320 each. Here is the journal entry that was recorded by Company ABC in its books:

Bank 640
Cost of Sales 400
Sales - Televisions 640
Inventory – Televisions 400
  • Sales = $320 x 2 units = $640
  • Cost of sales = $200 x 2 units = $400

For the sake of simplicity, let’s assume that no other transactions occurred during 2018. Here are the account balances for Inventory and Cost of sales using the T account:

T accoounts (3.96kb)

Scenario# 1

Suppose that on December 31, television selling prices have declined. The Bix Model 500 television retail price per unit dropped from $320 to $180, and the estimated cost to be incurred to make the sale is $10 per television.

As of December 31, 2018, 8 units remain in inventory, so the cost of inventory on hand is $1,600 (8 units x $200). Let’s determine the net realizable value for these 8 units:

Calculation1 (3.96kb)

Conclusion

The net realizable value of $1,360, is lower than the cost of $1,600. We can conclude that the cost of inventories may not be recoverable. In this case, the inventory should be written down to adjust it to the net realizable value of $1,360 by recording the following entry:

Cost of Sales 240
Inventory – Televisions 240
  • Adjustment = $1,600 - 1,360 = $240

Here are the general leger balances of inventories and cost of sales accounts after the adjustment:

Calculation1 (3.96kb)

Accordingly, the carrying amount of inventories presented on the balance sheet is now $1,360.

Scenario# 2

Suppose that on December 31, television selling prices have declined. The Bix Model 500 television retail price dropped from $320 to $240, and the estimated cost to be incurred to make the sale is $10 per television.

Let’s determine the net realizable value for these 8 units:

Calculation2 (3.91kb)

Conclusion

This time, the cost of $1,600 is lower than the net realizable value of $1,840. No need for an adjustment. The carrying amount of inventories on the balance sheet remains $1,600.

Rational behind the standard

How does complying with the above standard improves the quality and fairness of the information presented in the financial statements?

Imagine you have friend who bought a car for $10,000 in 2017. It is now the month of June 2018. The selling price of the car dropped to $5,000. Your friend asked you to loan him $7,000 for one month. You told him you are worried about his ability to pay back the loan. To reassure you he says “In case I don’t have money, I will sell my car and pay you back with the proceeds.” Is the information presented by your friend accurate and fair? Absolutely not – If you loan him the $7,000, it is more likely that your friend will not be able to pay back the full balance, because if he has financial problems and sells his car, he will get only $5,000. If your friend presents to you the right information regarding the actual value of the car, you will consider that risk and therefore make a better decision.

The same way you need to have the right information about the value of the car, the same way users of the financial information need to have the right information about the carrying amount of inventories in order to better assess the risks and make better decisions.

1. CPA Canada Standards, section 3031, paragraph 10

Author of this article:
Mahmoud Kessi, CPA, CGA
mkessi@kessi-cpa.com
(204) 226-9576

Comments & Questions

Good tutorial thank you!

Reply
2

I agree. Very useful discussion of this standard

Reply
3

Where can I find more information about measurement of retail inventories?

Reply

Do you have access to the CPA handbook?

2
4

Add New Comment or Question




Post

REPLY/COMMENT



Email Link


Link to be shared:

Confirmation

×

Copyright © 2016-2019 KESSI Chartered Professional Accountant Ltd.